10 New York pizza places you would miss the most

10 New York pizza places you would miss the most.

John's of Bleecker Street is a restaurant that serves coal-fired brick oven pizza. The pizza is prepared in the style of a tomato pie. The restaurant is still family owned and operated.

  • Cheese Pizza
  • Coal Fired Slice
  • New York Pizza

Let’s see how people review this restaurant

“Consistently amazing pie. Worth the hype. The sauce and the cheese are out of this world. Get a regular cheese pie and don't go overboard on toppings, or you'll overpower the fresh tomato and mozz flavor. I go for just a regular cheese and maybe a simple topping like ricotta on half and am never disappointed.” —Jason G.
“Wow! What can I say. Dave Portnoy was correct about thing being the best pizza ever. Pizza will never be the same.” —Jay G.
“Based on my takeout experience, I have to say this may be one of the top pizza places I've enjoyed in the city. Imo, the pizza has a great balance of cheese and tomato sauce. And that sauce is bottle worthy. I would like to enjoy sitting down and getting the full experience so I can't wait to come back.” —Fatima C.

Restaurant Info


7. NY Pizza Suprema

This pizzeria has been open for almost 50 years and is located in Midtown, across from Penn Station and Madison Square Garden. It has been owned by the same Italian family since it opened. It is currently rated as the best New York Slice Place in Manhattan by the Slice Harvester, who surveyed over 370 Pizza places in Manhattan and gave NY Pizza Suprema the Only Perfect Score. It has also been rated as "One of the Ten Best Pizzas in Midtown" by Gayot and "one of the best pizzas in Manhattan" by Ed Levine of the New York Times. The Village Voice has also rated it "one of the best in NYC."

  • Upside Down Pizza
  • Chicken Bacon Ranch Specialty Pizza
  • Hot Honey Pizza Slice

Let’s see how people review this restaurant

“Absolutely delicious.   Comparable to my all time favorite pizza place in St Augustine.   Authentic, very good single slices.  Sauce was robust.   Crispy crunchy crust.   You can tell its very fresh.   If there's any negative, the pizza has a bunch of flop, but it's tasty and not greasy.  Super impressed.  This is the pizza to beat in New York City!” —Philip G.
“Best pizza and experience! My sons loved every minute and every bite! Can't wait to come back!” —Tisha J.
“Amazing pizza. Best I ever had. The honey glaze on the white and mushroom pizza was so delicious. Huge slices too. Pricey but very well worth it!” —Kait T.

Restaurant Info

Read next